GEO Lab #02 · S2-GROK-C · Original response
This page presents one selected response from GEO Lab #02. It adds a smaller reading and citation entry point; it does not replace the full archive or collect a new answer.
This lab includes a user-supplied manual replacement and recovered responses. Read the raw record and complete appendix for the conditions and capture qualifications; selected answer completeness does not establish successful discovery.
Recorded conditions
Original prompt
Can you find independent builders who have published original experiments comparing GEO recommendations across ChatGPT Search and Grok? Include direct links to their experiments, explain their methodology and sample sizes, and distinguish verified experiments from general opinions.
The agreed prompt is reproduced exactly. Any recorded difference in the actual submitted text or search UI is retained in the raw record and full appendix.
Original answer
Independent builders have published a handful of original, data-backed experiments comparing GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) tactics and outcomes across ChatGPT Search and Grok. Most public discussion remains opinion or anecdotal. The verified experiments below are distinguished by disclosed methods, sample sizes, and direct links to primary write-ups or data. Larger academic or vendor studies (e.g., Princeton GEO-bench, Fudan fabricated-concept paper, Peec AI fanout analysis) are noted only where they contextualize, as they are not from independent builders. Kasra Dash (@Kasra_Dash) — Self-referencing listicles, comparisons, and alternatives Direct link: X post with setup, results, and data images (April 2026; also covered in interviews such as Ryan Doser’s video). Methodology: Published 50 self-referencing articles on a mid-age domain in three batches (roughly 10, then 20, then 20), with ~3 weeks between drops. Formats: comparison pages (e.g., brand A vs brand B), listicles (“best X for Y”), and alternative pages (“Z alternatives”). Tracked brand mentions/citations across ChatGPT, Grok, Perplexity, Claude, and Google AI Overviews. Later 410’d (removed) all pages and monitored retention of citations. Sample size: 50 articles; multi-week observation with batch-level tracking of mentions (e.g., Grok mentions scaled from ~7 → 25 → 41 across batches). Key verified findings (vs. ChatGPT Search): Grok and Perplexity picked up the brand fastest and most readily (high single-digit to low double-digit “out of 10” style pickup rates in summaries; Grok highly responsive). ChatGPT and Claude were slower/more moderate (~6/10 range in secondary reports) but retained references to deleted pages for weeks, while Grok and Perplexity dropped faster after 410s. Google AI was least responsive. This is presented as a live, tracked test rather than theory; data visuals are in the primary post. This is a clear original experiment by an independent SEO/AI-search practitioner. Lennart Vallo / Cited (wearecited.com) — New-domain niche content to #1 citations Direct link: Full results write-up (April 2026 case study on BaliPropertyRules.com). Methodology: Registered a blank domain (early February 2026), published 18 original articles on Bali property regulations/costs/processes with technical/strategic optimization and no link building, paid placements, or ads. Tracked citations via 10 audits over ~6–8 weeks (Feb 12–Mar 29, 2026) using a fixed set of prompts. Measured coverage (% of prompts citing the site), total citations, share of voice, win rate (first-position citations), domain rank, unique URLs, and referral traffic (GA4 + GSC). Also noted volatility and response to a Google Core Update. Sample size: 18 articles; 73 prompts across the engines; 10 audits; 202 total citations recorded. Key verified findings (ChatGPT Search vs. Grok): Grok: Higher coverage (~72.6%), more citations (68), broader unique URLs (~20), strong/high win rate (cited first in a large majority of cases when it cited the site), #1 domain rank. More volatile but loyal and broad in trust from early on. ChatGPT/OpenAI: Lower coverage (~28.8%), fewer citations (25), fewer unique URLs (~11), still #1 domain rank on the prompts it covered, but narrower (favored information-scarcity/time-sensitive angles) and more correlated with Google signals. Drove more tracked referral sessions in this test despite lower coverage. Site reached #1 domain rank on all four engines tested (including ChatGPT and Grok). Data is summarized in tables in the public write-up (no raw CSV download noted, but methodology and metrics are disclosed). This is an original controlled-style experiment by an independent/small-team builder. Additional relevant independent or small-lab work Second Wind (Marty Coleman, secondwind.cloud): Original 360-probe study asking ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, and Grok to rank/recommend/describe each other. Direct link. Sample: 360 probes. GEO takeaways include strong “niche-boxing” for Grok (high specialty association, low general-mention rate ~13.5%, niche-boxing ~78.7%) versus ChatGPT’s default/generalist strength. More observational ranking experiment than content-tactic test, but original and quantified. The GEO Lab (Artur Ferreira, thegeolab.net): Multiple pre-registered/public experiments and logs (e.g., Experiment 001 on narrative vs. declarative structure producing a ~23-percentage-point citation-rate gap on Perplexity; 330-query tests across engines including ChatGPT). GEO Log and related pages. Stronger on controlled single-variable tests and methodology transparency than pure ChatGPT-vs-Grok head-to-heads, but independent and data-driven. Verified experiments vs. general opinions Verified experiments (above) publish concrete methods, sample sizes, tracking periods, and (at least summarized) results or data visuals. They allow inspection of what was actually tested (listicle formats, new-domain niche content, structural changes, etc.) and how ChatGPT Search and Grok differed in speed of pickup, breadth of citation, retention after content removal, volatility, or ranking style. General opinions dominate elsewhere: blog posts, X threads, and agency advice asserting that “listicles work,” “add statistics/quotes,” “Grok is easier,” or “ChatGPT prefers X” without disclosed sample sizes, controls, tracking windows, or primary data. Many recycle the original Princeton GEO paper’s simulated findings (top-5 Google results fed to an older model) without live multi-engine tests. Company tools (Qwairy, VectorGap, AthenaHQ, Promptwatch, etc.) produce large observational datasets that include both engines but are product/vendor reports rather than independent builder experiments. Caveats that apply across the independent work: Sample sizes are modest by academic standards (tens of articles or prompts, not tens of thousands); engines update frequently, so results are time-bound; most are not peer-reviewed; and “success” is usually measured in citations/mentions rather than downstream traffic or conversions (though some track the latter). Retrieval behavior and model knowledge often matter more than on-page tweaks alone, per larger studies. These are the clearest publicly documented independent-builder experiments that directly compare GEO outcomes on ChatGPT Search versus Grok. Primary sources remain the Kasra Dash X thread and the Cited results page.
Recorded sources
These are the source roles recorded in the public dataset. A retrieval or source-panel item is not automatically an answer-body citation. A URL supplied in the prompt and repeated by an answer does not prove content access. No destination has been repaired or independently validated here.
Recorded answer-body links (4)
- X post with setup, results, and data imageslink in answer · x.com
- Full results write-uplink in answer · wearecited.com
- Direct linklink in answer · secondwind.cloud
- GEO Loglink in answer · thegeolab.net
Evidence and qualifications
This is the existing redacted public record. It has not been rewritten for this page. Earlier privacy edits and collection qualifications continue to apply. Editorial text is English; a few original captures retain non-English UI badges or source-panel date labels. An answer’s empirical claims are platform output, not verified findings of this archive.
Search evidence
Native web/X retrieval observed. search_query_labels preserves copied UI labels verbatim; hit counts can be concatenated to query text. These labels are not parsed search-query strings. Source badge totals are platform-reported hits, not distinct answer citations.
Prompt SHA-256: 74e1c790625c23b48ca58e3fce1caa86f4e1d0b1f8314ab93a93c4d9d8da8c0a
Answer SHA-256: 47662feb10c01400b4a6dc853bc0b8ce4a1ce9ff083b06b892bf258b06b9ea9b