{
  "id": "S3-GROK-V2-R1",
  "source_record": "records/S3-GROK-V2-R1.json",
  "coding_method": "Assistant review of complete copied answer and existing native UI/activity/citation-group captures. No external webpage access or fact verification; no independent human double-coding.",
  "coding_scope": "Substantively named tools, services and AI surfaces. Generic methods and supplied platforms separate. Citation-only publishers excluded from default tool overlap.",
  "answer_type": {
    "primary": "Score validation or audit checklist",
    "secondary": [
      "Manual measurement workflow",
      "Conceptual explanation"
    ],
    "evidence": "Demand full methodology details",
    "rationale": "Five numbered audit/validation dimensions dominate; manual replication and corroborating analytics support the checks. No named AI visibility checker is recommended."
  },
  "content_flags": {
    "branded_and_unbranded_buyer_prompts": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "The specific prompt set and how it was chosen (real buyer-intent questions vs. branded or generic ones)."
    },
    "repeated_runs": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Run each prompt 3\u20135 times in the actual consumer interfaces your buyers use: ChatGPT with search/browsing enabled, and Grok."
    },
    "fresh_sessions": {
      "value": false,
      "evidence": null
    },
    "model_search_version_logging": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Sampling: how many runs per prompt, which models/versions, web search on or off, date of collection, and whether it used the consumer web interface or an API."
    },
    "search_mode_logging_explicit": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "web search on or off"
    },
    "citations_mentions_recommendations_distinguished": {
      "value": false,
      "evidence": null
    },
    "citation_and_mention_rates_separate": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Track mention rate, citation rate, position, accuracy, and share of voice versus 3\u20135 competitors."
    },
    "raw_answer_inspection": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Prefer tools that publish methodology, raw answers, or scoring code, or that let you inspect the underlying responses."
    },
    "numerator_denominator_definition": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Denominator (all answers vs. only answers that mention at least one brand)."
    },
    "composite_score_weighting_disclosed_or_checked": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Exact formula and weights (mention rate, share of voice, position/prominence, citations, sentiment, adversarial resistance, etc.)."
    },
    "composite_score_caution": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Per-engine breakdowns rather than a single blended score."
    },
    "uncertainty_variance": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "AI answers are stochastic."
    },
    "human_checking": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Replicate the core results yourself"
    },
    "downstream_conversions": {
      "value": true,
      "evidence": "Direct customer attribution (\u201cHow did you hear about us?\u201d)."
    },
    "paid_tool_dependence": {
      "value": false,
      "evidence": null
    }
  },
  "entity_observations": [
    {
      "entity": "Google Analytics 4",
      "observed_name": "GA4",
      "entity_type": "analytics",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested",
      "free_budget_fit": "stated free",
      "evidence": "GA4 referrals from chatgpt.com, grok-related domains, or similar.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Explicitly suggested as a free corroborating traffic signal; manually normalized GA4 alias, not a composite visibility tool."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Google Search Console",
      "observed_name": "Google Search Console",
      "entity_type": "analytics",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "conditional",
      "free_budget_fit": "stated free",
      "evidence": "Google Search Console data on AI Overviews / AI Mode impressions (where available).",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "The where-available qualification and claimed AI surface coverage are retained as platform output, not verified product capabilities."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Reddit",
      "observed_name": "Reddit",
      "entity_type": "community_corroborating_signal",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested",
      "free_budget_fit": "stated free",
      "evidence": "Community and third-party presence (Reddit, review sites, GitHub, directories, X engagement)\u2014these heavily influence what the models say.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "The suggested action is checking existing third-party presence, not necessarily posting or adopting a new tool."
    },
    {
      "entity": "GitHub",
      "observed_name": "GitHub",
      "entity_type": "developer_community_corroborating_signal",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested",
      "free_budget_fit": "stated free",
      "evidence": "Community and third-party presence (Reddit, review sites, GitHub, directories, X engagement)\u2014these heavily influence what the models say.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Named as a corroborating presence signal; no GitHub source is cited and no publication action is requested."
    },
    {
      "entity": "X",
      "observed_name": "X (Twitter); X engagement",
      "entity_type": "community_corroborating_signal",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested",
      "free_budget_fit": "stated free",
      "evidence": "Community and third-party presence (Reddit, review sites, GitHub, directories, X engagement)\u2014these heavily influence what the models say.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Twitter is explicitly treated as an alias for X. The recommendation concerns observing presence/engagement, not a directive to publish content."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Claude",
      "observed_name": "Claude",
      "entity_type": "ai_platform",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": false,
      "recommendation_stance": "discussed",
      "free_budget_fit": "unspecified",
      "evidence": "A single blended number can also hide large engine differences (e.g., strong on Grok/Claude but near-zero on ChatGPT).",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Illustrative engine difference, not a recommendation to use Claude."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Bing",
      "observed_name": "Bing-derived",
      "entity_type": "search_platform",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": false,
      "recommendation_stance": "discussed",
      "free_budget_fit": "unspecified",
      "evidence": "ChatGPT relies more on training data plus web retrieval (historically Bing-derived) and favors established third-party authority, directories, reviews, and consistent entity coverage.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Historical retrieval-source attribution, not a suggested tool. No Bing citation is captured."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Google AI Overviews",
      "observed_name": "AI Overviews",
      "entity_type": "ai_search_surface",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": false,
      "recommendation_stance": "discussed",
      "free_budget_fit": "unspecified",
      "evidence": "Google Search Console data on AI Overviews / AI Mode impressions (where available).",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Mentioned as claimed analytics coverage. The recommendation is to cross-check GSC data, not independently to use this AI surface."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Google AI Mode",
      "observed_name": "AI Mode",
      "entity_type": "ai_search_surface",
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": false,
      "recommendation_stance": "discussed",
      "free_budget_fit": "unspecified",
      "evidence": "Google Search Console data on AI Overviews / AI Mode impressions (where available).",
      "source_urls": [],
      "notes": "Mentioned as claimed analytics coverage, not independently recommended."
    }
  ],
  "supplied_entities": [
    {
      "entity": "ChatGPT",
      "supplied_in_prompt": true,
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested for manual replication",
      "evidence": "Run each prompt 3\u20135 times in the actual consumer interfaces your buyers use: ChatGPT with search/browsing enabled, and Grok.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "excluded_from_default_overlap": true,
      "notes": "Explicitly suggested for checks, but supplied in the question and excluded from discovered tool overlap by default."
    },
    {
      "entity": "Grok",
      "supplied_in_prompt": true,
      "citation": false,
      "mention": true,
      "recommendation": true,
      "recommendation_stance": "suggested for manual replication",
      "evidence": "Run each prompt 3\u20135 times in the actual consumer interfaces your buyers use: ChatGPT with search/browsing enabled, and Grok.",
      "source_urls": [],
      "excluded_from_default_overlap": true,
      "notes": "Explicitly suggested for checks, but supplied in the question and excluded from discovered tool overlap by default."
    }
  ],
  "contextual_non_tool_entities": [],
  "generic_methods": [
    "Unnamed spreadsheet with fixed buyer prompts",
    "Competitor-relative comparisons within identical prompt sets",
    "Weekly/biweekly repeated consumer-interface runs",
    "Review sites and directories as corroborating presence signals",
    "Direct customer attribution",
    "Inspecting vendor methodology, underlying raw answers and score code"
  ],
  "answer_sources": [
    {
      "text": "AI visibility score: what it is and how it's calculated | Visilay (Visilay)",
      "observed_target": "visilay.com/blog/ai-visibility-score/",
      "url": "https://visilay.com/blog/ai-visibility-score/",
      "domain": "visilay.com",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Other / unresolved",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "Title and expanded card describe an explanatory article about visibility-score formulas. Vendor documentation, practitioner tutorial or original vendor research is not established from the available metadata.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    },
    {
      "text": "AI visibility score: what it is and how it's calculated | Visilay (Visilay)",
      "observed_target": "visilay.com/blog/ai-visibility-score/",
      "url": "https://visilay.com/blog/ai-visibility-score/",
      "domain": "visilay.com",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Other / unresolved",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "Title and expanded card describe an explanatory article about visibility-score formulas. Vendor documentation, practitioner tutorial or original vendor research is not established from the available metadata.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    },
    {
      "text": "There Is No Single \u201cAI Visibility\u201d Score; Ask Four AIs, Get Four Shortlists | Markets Insider (Markets.businessinsider)",
      "observed_target": "markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/there-is-no-single-ai-visibility-score-ask-four-ais-get-four-shortlists-1036643461",
      "url": "https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/there-is-no-single-ai-visibility-score-ask-four-ais-get-four-shortlists-1036643461",
      "domain": "markets.businessinsider.com",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Editorial or industry reporting",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "Returned title reports a multi-engine shortlist study. The /news/stocks/ path also permits syndicated/promotional material; primary research authorship is unresolved.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    },
    {
      "text": "There Is No Single \u201cAI Visibility\u201d Score; Ask Four AIs, Get Four Shortlists | Markets Insider (Markets.businessinsider)",
      "observed_target": "markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/there-is-no-single-ai-visibility-score-ask-four-ais-get-four-shortlists-1036643461",
      "url": "https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/there-is-no-single-ai-visibility-score-ask-four-ais-get-four-shortlists-1036643461",
      "domain": "markets.businessinsider.com",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Editorial or industry reporting",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "Returned title reports a multi-engine shortlist study. The /news/stocks/ path also permits syndicated/promotional material; primary research authorship is unresolved.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    },
    {
      "text": "Grok Is Citing Brands Too: The Data Behind Its Citation Logic | Am I Cited (Amicited)",
      "observed_target": "amicited.com/blog/grok-is-citing-brands-too/",
      "url": "https://amicited.com/blog/grok-is-citing-brands-too/",
      "domain": "amicited.com",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Other / unresolved",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "A branded blog title claims data about Grok citation logic; original empirical study versus commercial explanatory content is unresolved.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    },
    {
      "text": "Are AI Visibility Tools Accurate? What They Miss (2026) (Searchscope)",
      "observed_target": "searchscope.com.au/ai-seo/how-accurate-are-ai-visibility-tools/",
      "url": "https://searchscope.com.au/ai-seo/how-accurate-are-ai-visibility-tools/",
      "domain": "searchscope.com.au",
      "kind": "Inline answer link",
      "provenance": "Native accessibility target; displayed targets omit scheme, standardized to HTTPS; www may be omitted by display",
      "source_category": "Other / unresolved",
      "classification_status": "provisional_from_returned_title_URL_and_captured_UI_card_only",
      "classification_evidence": "Title and /ai-seo/ path suggest explanatory/practitioner or commercial content, without establishing author or original research.",
      "content_verified": false,
      "recommendation_role": "supporting citation; no active recommendation to use or follow the publisher"
    }
  ],
  "cited_hostname_set": [
    "visilay.com",
    "markets.businessinsider.com",
    "amicited.com",
    "searchscope.com.au"
  ],
  "registrable_domain_mapping": {
    "method": "Explicit manual mapping, retaining displayed hostnames. Market Insider hostname collapsed to businessinsider.com; searchscope.com.au retained. Leading www variants treated as same normalized domain, not as proof of exact href. No public-suffix software or external lookup used.",
    "mapping": {
      "visilay.com": "visilay.com",
      "markets.businessinsider.com": "businessinsider.com",
      "amicited.com": "amicited.com",
      "searchscope.com.au": "searchscope.com.au"
    }
  },
  "capture_scope": {
    "body_complete": true,
    "observed_inline_link_occurrences": 6,
    "unique_standardized_answer_URLs": 4,
    "unique_displayed_answer_domains": 4,
    "source_badge_hits": 45,
    "retrieval_inventory_complete": false,
    "citation_mapping_complete": null,
    "search_observed": true,
    "search_enabled_UI": null,
    "activity_evidence_file": "[Private capture retained locally.]",
    "citation_group_evidence_file": "[Private capture retained locally.]",
    "native_browsed_link_domains": [
      "markets.businessinsider.com",
      "visilay.com",
      "searchscope.com.au"
    ],
    "captured_exact_query_labels": [
      "Grok AI visibility scoring how Grok differs from ChatGPT in brand mentions"
    ],
    "notes": [
      "Visilay and Markets Insider each occur twice in the recorded inline list. Deduplicate for domain/URL set comparisons; retain six link occurrences separately.",
      "Expanding Visilay +1 revealed Visilay and Markets Insider, both already recorded. This does not add two unique sources.",
      "Captured displayed targets omit the scheme and may omit www. The standardized https URLs are not independently recovered exact hrefs. The citation-group capture separately displays https://www.visilay.com/blog/ai-visibility-score/. Domain comparison is robust to this leading-www difference; exact-URL equivalence beyond that is not asserted.",
      "Native activity directly shows a grouped three-search control, a separate web-search query label and browsed-link controls. Actual search is observed independently of the 45-hit badge. Exact query-label coverage remains partial.",
      "The raw notes retain an earlier statement that activity needed reopening; the later search_observed=true and explicit activity capture supersede that pending status without changing the historical note.",
      "Workspace-explored activity is visible, but contents and influence are unestablished; isolation is not audited.",
      "Saved HTML lacking the rendered answer DOM is not treated as an independent complete body/citation capture.",
      "All research statistics, relative engine behavior, analytics capabilities and costs are platform claims, not verified facts."
    ],
    "original_capture_answer_characters": 5038,
    "answer_characters": 5038,
    "public_copy_note": "Body length and source hash describe this redacted public record. Original citation position indexes are omitted; semantic judgments are retained."
  },
  "summary": {
    "substantive_tools_services_features": 9,
    "citation_true": 0,
    "mention_true": 9,
    "recommendation_true": 5,
    "visibility_checker_recommendations": [],
    "default_mentioned_tools": [
      "Google Analytics 4",
      "Google Search Console",
      "Reddit",
      "GitHub",
      "X",
      "Claude",
      "Bing",
      "Google AI Overviews",
      "Google AI Mode"
    ],
    "default_recommended_tools": [
      "Google Analytics 4",
      "Google Search Console",
      "Reddit",
      "GitHub",
      "X"
    ],
    "supplied_target_platforms_excluded": 2,
    "inline_link_occurrences": 6,
    "unique_answer_URLs": 4,
    "unique_cited_domains": 4
  },
  "coding_cautions": [
    "Recommended corroborating channels are counted separately by role from score-checking software; monitoring existing community presence is not a publication recommendation.",
    "Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are contextual coverage mentions. Coding the GSC recommendation as a recommendation of every named covered surface would overcount tools.",
    "Citation labels name Visilay, Markets Insider, Am I Cited and Searchscope, but the substantive prose does not name or recommend them. No complete source-publisher C/M/R census is added to default tool counts.",
    "C=false means no own-content link observed in the captured answer links; missing full retrieval inventory is not automatically a missing citation.",
    "The answer separates mention/citation metrics but does not explicitly operationalize active recommendation rate as a third metric."
  ],
  "source_record_sha256": "ebf90c9b23204aca70f144e04f49d2f992e8d50cbc06996002938e4dbae1f405"
}
